CLINIQUE Lid Smoothie antioxidant 8-hour eye colour in 01 bit o' honey

I bought this product in the hunt for a quick and easy everyday lid colour. First of all, it comes in a cream form, which I find very appealing as I have quite dry skin and I love dewiness all year round. I thought it would be suitable for both a light summery glowy make-up look and a quick pick-me-up look that would take me through the day when I have classes at the Uni. 

 Let's see if what the company claims is true:

-"Creamy, crease-resistant eye colour wears for 8 hours."

The eyeshadow is definitely creamy, but or a high-end product you expect at least to get the texture right. It does spread easily without slipping too much and it allows you to blend the edges before it sets. I didn't notice much creasing even without a primer but I don't have particularly oily eyelids anyway. The problem was that the application wasn't even to begin with, which bring us to the third claim:
-"Nourishing ingredients coax fine lid lines into a blanket of smoothness."

There are few nourishing ingredients in the formula (Glycerin, Carnauba Wax as well as Aloe Barbadensis leaf water). However, not only it doesn't fill the lid lines but it also accentuates them! Even using a small amount of product, I couldn't get it to apply evenly.

"Instantly cools thanks to a unique applicator."

The applicator feels cooling indeed, but I can't see anyone applying it directly to the eyelid.

-"Antioxidants help protect eye-area skin."

Some of the ingredients (the fruit extracts mentioned above and caffeine) are found in eye creams, too, so I will have to give them credit for that. The tube ensures that air doesn't get in the product, which would destroy the antioxidants a few days after the opening. Although the packaging is transparent, if you keep it in a drawer I don't think you will have problems with the sun seeing it either.

-"Tip: A little goes a long way—start with a small amount and build with additional colour as desired."

True. You literally need the tiniest amount and it is buildable. In fact, you HAVE to start with a small quantity to get it right.

(The pictures above are taken after 4 hours of wear w/o primer, 8 hours of wear w/o primer and 12 hours of wear with Too Faced Shadow Insurance)

Overall, I expected more from this product, but I will still get a lot of use out of it. The colour is a very light in tone and very shimmery champagne colour. I am not a big fan of overly shimmery eyeshadows, but in this case it doesn't bother me. The reason being, I prefer to use a small amount of it, just to give a sheen to the eyelids for a more natural look. I feel that this works best for my skin tone because of the lightness of the colour, too. Moreover, I will use it as a primer underneath eyeshadows that are already very shimmery like the lighter shades in the MUA Undressed palette. If you have really oily eyelids, I wouldn't suggest using it as a primer though.

-Would I repurchase it? -Nah, the cream eyeshadow offerings are too many for me to go back to it.

-Can I find anything cheaper with similar results and/or ingredients? -I can find something cheaper with BETTER results. As for the ingredients, I won't probably see them in a lower-end product.

(Below there is a comparison with Chubby Sticks for eyes according to the site - I don't have any of these in my personal collection)